Section 24: Why Your Tax Bill Has Gone Up Even Though Your Profit Hasn't

If you're a landlord who has watched your tax bill climb year on year without any meaningful increase in your actual income, Section 24 is almost certainly the cause. It's one of the most significant and least understood changes to hit buy to let landlords in recent years — and for many, it's quietly making their portfolios far less profitable than they appear on paper.

What Section 24 Actually Changed

Before Section 24 was introduced, landlords could deduct their full mortgage interest costs from their rental income before calculating how much tax they owed. The logic was straightforward: mortgage interest is a genuine cost of running a rental property, so it made sense to treat it the same way any other business would treat a finance cost.

That approach has been replaced entirely.

Under the current rules, landlords pay income tax on their total rental income — not on their profit after mortgage costs. In place of the deduction, HMRC provides a tax credit worth 20% of your mortgage interest. For basic rate taxpayers, this largely replicates what they had before. For everyone else, it falls short.

A Simple Example

Say you earn £18,000 a year in rental income and pay £12,000 in mortgage interest. Under the old system, you'd be taxed on £6,000 of profit.

Under Section 24, you're taxed on the full £18,000. You then receive a credit worth 20% of £12,000 — that's £2,400 off your tax bill.

If you're a basic rate taxpayer paying 20%, your tax on £18,000 would be £3,600, minus the £2,400 credit — leaving a net tax bill of £1,200. Under the old system you'd have paid 20% of £6,000, which is also £1,200. So far so similar.

But if you're a higher rate taxpayer paying 40%, your tax on £18,000 is £7,200. Minus the same £2,400 credit, your bill is £4,800. Under the old rules you'd have paid 40% of £6,000 — just £2,400. Your tax bill has doubled, on the same income, from the same property.

The Bracket Trap

There's a further problem that catches many landlords off guard. Because Section 24 requires you to declare your full rental income rather than your net profit, some landlords have been pushed into higher rate tax territory purely on paper.

Your actual cash position may not have changed at all — your rent is the same, your mortgage costs are the same — but because HMRC now sees a larger gross income figure, you may find yourself paying 40% tax on income you never truly received as profit.

What Your Options Are

Section 24 is permanent. It's been fully phased in and there's no suggestion it will be reversed. So the question isn't whether to wait it out — it's how to manage it.

The option most widely discussed is moving properties into a *limited company*. Companies are not subject to Section 24 and can still deduct mortgage interest as a business expense in full. For landlords building a portfolio from scratch, purchasing through a limited company from the outset now makes strong financial sense in many cases.

For existing landlords considering transferring properties into a company, the calculation is more complex. The transfer is treated as a sale for both Stamp Duty Land Tax and Capital Gains Tax purposes, which means upfront costs that can be substantial. Whether those costs are worth bearing depends on your specific portfolio, your tax position, and your long term plans — and this is genuinely a decision that requires qualified accountancy advice rather than general guidance.

If you're a basic rate taxpayer and Section 24 isn't pushing you into the higher rate band, the impact on your position is relatively limited. The 20% credit broadly covers what you've lost.

For those approaching or crossing the higher rate threshold as a result of these rules, it's worth exploring other forms of tax planning alongside the incorporation question — including pension contributions, which can reduce your adjusted net income and potentially bring you back below the higher rate threshold.

The Bottom Line

Section 24 has fundamentally changed the economics of buy to let for higher rate taxpayers. It's no longer enough to look at rental yield and mortgage cost and assume you know what your return will be — your tax position is now a central part of that calculation, not an afterthought.

The landlords navigating this most effectively are those who have sat down with an accountant, understood exactly what Section 24 means for their specific circumstances, and made deliberate decisions about their structure accordingly. If you haven't done that yet, now is the time.